top of page
Non-Traditional Media

 

Colin Kaepernick’s movement has spread across the nation, dividing Americans on different issues. Traditional news and social media are not the only outlets used to express opinions about this controversy though. People from boths sides of the argument have creatively shown their views through non-traditional media like bumper stickers, political cartoons, clothing, decals, and more. Some examples of these alternative expressions from across the internet are displayed below. Most of the content from conservative media takes jabs at Kaepernick’s lack of respect for the US and soldiers as well as his understanding of what they believe the issue is. Meanwhile, liberal sources commonly portray Colin as a respectable hero and a figurehead of the BLM movement. Much of this non-traditional media is merchandising or political cartoons with right and left views apparent in both categories. Perceptions of Kaepernick vary greatly as evident from most of these examples. Depending on their stance creators will often only include information in their pieces that reflect and support their own views, showing that even alternative media distorts perspective to hide the full story. The media remains so one-sided to not acknowledge other perspectives because to do so would mean that they would have to have a civil and reasonable debate on topics like this. Those conversations seem more difficult in the eyes of many, but to actually debate (and we mean really debate with true information and open minds) would progress us as a people more than wallowing in our stubbornness. However, most people would rather stay in their corners finding new creative ways to blame their opponents for problems than to put aside their biases and try to resolve any issue.  

Merchandise:

​

The issue with most of these items is that they take a stance on the issue with minimal information and convey very little to their audience. Usually it’s either for or against with some slogan or popping visual that people may remember as an attempt to advertise their perspective while dragging the opposition through the mud. This media really won’t do much and often just acts as an creative expression of bias.

Bumper Stickers:

Many Americans express their political views through slogans on bumper stickers and the Kaepernick controversy is no exception. Neither of these items directly state that they are about Kaepernick, but it’s easy to infer that the phrases are attacks on his virtue. There are also stickers available that support Kaepernick with slogans like “I kneel with Kaepernick”, however pictures were not available.

Clothing:

Political views often show up on clothing so people can try to convey their thoughts on a topic without even having to talk. Colin has made his way onto t-shirts, tank tops, hats, and more both for and against him. The socks that depict police officers as pigs are a pair that he wore to a 49ers practice before this controversy (Rosenthal) and now his supporters have bought and worn pairs of them.

Prints:

There is often a political tie to prints as in the first two. The left picture connects Kaepernick’s fight against oppression and the American government to the man in Tiananmen Square protesting the Chinese government in 1989. The middle poster illustrates Colin in a way similar to Obama’s HOPE poster that was iconic during his 2008 campaign; this would appeal to democrats and indicates that Kaepernick is bringing about hope and change. However, not all prints tie directly to politics as evident in the last, minimalistic print that would show support for the 49ers and Kaepernick.

Lapel Pins:

Accent pieces and collector’s items that express support for Kaepernick and BLM. There’s not much substance to these items, but they still convey a message endorsing Kaepernick.

Toys:

This media is directed towards children and doesn’t provide much of any content. Children more than likely won’t be involved in heated discussion about politics and don’t need a lot of information, but these Kaepernick items are marketed nonetheless.

A Bar in Florida:

Lakeland, Florida’s Winners Circle Sportsbar & Grill owned by Bill Alcock recently put down Kaepernick’s #7 jersey as a doormat and decals of the jersey in the men’s room urinals. Alcock’s father was a marine and thought “[Kaepernick] was very, very disrespectful” and  made these additions to his bar because he “thought it would be a funny kind of tribute, non-tribute to him” (Nguyen). Customers found it funny and regarding Kaepernick’s first amendment right to Alcock said “I do believe in freedom of speech and everything like that, but it’s just a little message that you don’t disrespect the flag, and don’t disrespect our military. That’s what I think it is. This gives you a little chance to disrespect his jersey, a target of sorts” (Nguyen). This media doesn’t provide any context of the issues at hand, but only an outlet for opponents of Kaepernick.

Political Cartoons:

​

Political cartoons are a creative and sometimes humorous form of social commentary. These illustrations are much more politically involved (as their name would suggest) than the merchandise above and there are some that are similarly one-sided, but more often the cartoons express irony surrounding the controversy. Below are some prime examples of biased media as well as content from artists aware of the irony revolving around both sides of the argument.

Illustrator Matt Davies plays on the irony that supporters of  Trump in the 2016 election generally are not supportive of Kaepernick’s actions while they are preaching the same message. Connections between current events like this are common in political cartoons. This is one of the pieces that doesn’t necessarily take a bias approaching the issue and makes the audience think more in-depth about their own beliefs. Davies still misconstrues information like the rest of the media discussed by excluding the different reasons that the two men have, but examples like this are steps in a better direction for the media.

This illustration by Tom Stiglich builds on the patriotism that most of Kaepernick’s claim to have. He suggests that Kaepernick should have more respect for the US and its anthem through iconic military gravestones representative of those who paid the ultimate price for their country. This example is biased against Kaepernick, but as evident in the next picture the media can construe the same information to reflect different points.

This illustration (Tornoe) provides an antithesis to the last while using the same military tombstones to argue the opposite on Stiglich’s work. These two political cartoons exemplify how the media can distort the same content to show entirely different perspectives. Media is a matter of opinion and that means the bias of people will get in the way of accurate stories and understanding between parties. People don’t want to discuss their opponents views so they don’t and progress becomes a standstill.

The image to the right drawn by Keith Knight reflects the wide variety of views that focus on the subject of Kaepernick. However, there is a clear lack of understanding between many of the opinions and that means no substantial debate to reach possible solutions to the issues that are claimed to be important. “Divided We Sit” alludes to Abraham Lincoln’s famous words “United we stand, divided we fall” and reflects two stubborn sides of an argument. This issue applies not only to Kaepernick, but most media stories and political problems in today’s society.

More political cartoons on the topic of Kaepernick that reflect a variety of perspectives are shown below for your browsing leisure.

The images on this page are courtesy of:

​

"Anthem Bumper Sticker." Zazzle, 2016. http://www.zazzle.com/anthem_bumper_sticker-128180130640087740

 

“Colin Kaepernick Action Figure White Jersey.” McFarlane CLARKtoys.com, 2016. http://www.clarktoys.com/cokawhjesfr4.html  

 

“Colin Kaepernick Lapel Pin.”Radical Dreams, 2016. http://www.radicaldreams.net/product/i-sit-with-kapernick-lapel-pin

 

Davies, Matt. "America's Not Great." Newsday, 2016. http://projects.newsday.com/cartoons/opinion/matt-davies-political-cartoons/?fb_ref=Default#!/item/1413/americas-not-great

 

“FREEdom Lapel Pin.”Radical Dreams, 2016. http://www.radicaldreams.net/product/freedom-lapel-pin

 

IndustrialAge. “Colin Kaepernick MINIMALISM limited edition art print.” Etsy, Etsy, Inc., 2016. https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/241202847/colin-kaepernick-minimalism-limited?ref=market

 

 

Knight, Keith. "Cartoon: Kaepernick." 30 Aug. 2016. http://www.dailykos.com/story/2016/8/30/1565274/-Cartoon-Kaepernick.

MADEbyJIMBOB. “Kaepernick + Tiananmen Square | 8x10" Print.” Etsy, Etsy, Inc., 2016. https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/480823910/kaepernick-tiananmen-square-8x10-print?ga_order=most_relevant&ga_search_type=all&ga_view_type=gallery&ga_search_query=kaepernick&ref=sr_gallery_23

 

Marino, Melissa, Julian Grace, and Vi Nguyen. "Florida Bar Puts Kaepernick Jersey Decals in Urinals." WISH-TV, 2016. http://wishtv.com/2016/09/27/florida-bar-puts-kaepernick-jersey-decals-in-urinals/

 

ManateezApparel. “Ladies Racer Back Tank Top - Boycott Kaepernick - No Number 7.” Etsy, Etsy, Inc., 2016. https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/465313492/ladies-racer-back-tank-top-boycott?ga_order=most_relevant&ga_search_type=all&ga_view_type=gallery&ga_search_query=kaepernick&ref=sr_gallery_15

 

“POP! SPORTS: NFL - COLIN KAEPERNICK.” Funko, 2016 https://funko.com/products/pop-sports-nfl-colin-kaepernick

​

“SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS COLIN KAEPERNICK 10" PLUSH FIGURE.” Bleacher Creatures, 2016. http://www.bleachercreatures.com/san-francisco-49ers-colin-kaepernick-plush-figure-10.html?gclid=CjwKEAiAjvrBBRDxm_nRusW3q1QSJAAzRI1tu5Bh-ySDKZesP4PEk7Q7ClzdcIpvcXLbQRUyAVCv4xoC163w_wcB

 

"Sitting Out The Season Bumper Sticker." Zazzle, 2016. http://www.zazzle.com/sitting_out_the_season_bumper_sticker-128876206328274503

 

Splendid Printables. “Colin Kaepernick Poster - Hope NFL Print Sports Poster 49ers.” Etsy, Etsy, Inc., 2016. https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/252030679/colin-kaepernick-poster-printable-wall?ga_order=most_relevant&ga_search_type=all&ga_view_type=gallery&ga_search_query=kaepernick&ref=sr_gallery_33

 

Stiglich, Tom “400,000 Reasons 49ers QB Colin Kaepernick Should Stand During the National Anthem.” 2016. http://tomstiglich.com/editorials.html

 

TipsyTz. “Colin Kaepernick - Police Pig Socks.” Etsy, Etsy, Inc., 2016. https://www.etsy.com/listing/476558025/colin-kaepernick-police-pig-socks?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=shopping_us_e-clothing-unisex_adult_clothing-socks_and_hosiery&utm_custom1=8edc7bd2-72b0-48fe-82ce-163c22cce640&gclid=CjwKEAiAjvrBBRDxm_nRusW3q1QSJAAzRI1tHMrGnNciYzKW9aQ70RDkHl52lDXRoO1iiYH11ZDaIRoC0mrw_wcB

 

Tornoe, Rob. “Who Gave 49ers Quarterback Colin Kaepernick the Right to Disrespect the Flag?.” Forbes, 31 Aug. 2016. http://www.forbes.com/sites/cartoonoftheday/2016/08/31/who-gave-49ers-quarterback-colin-kaepernick-the-right-to-disrespect-the-flag/#326118174a5f

 

VintageBrooklynNYC. “Maroon Colin Kaepernick Taking A Knee Exclusive Dad Cap.” Etsy, Etsy, Inc., 2016. https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/482497921/maroon-colin-kaepernick-taking-a-knee?ga_order=most_relevant&ga_search_type=all&ga_view_type=gallery&ga_search_query=kaepernick&ref=sr_gallery_9

​

YourDigitalCreator. “I sit with COLIN KAEPERNICK T-shirt.” Etsy, Etsy, Inc., 2016. https://www.etsy.com/listing/478028097/i-sit-with-colin-kaepernick-t-shirt-san?utm_campaign=shopping_us_YourDigitalCreator_sfc_osa&utm_medium=cpc&utm_source=google&utm_custom1=0&utm_content=9862491&gclid=CjwKEAiAjvrBBRDxm_nRusW3q1QSJAAzRI1tnXB4Ml75xb-iCxltkeSgQRBfqw2exzp0BIwMmqDAOhoCTE_w_wcB

 

bottom of page